When Jessica Taige started making peanut butter cups from a random recipe she found online, there was no way for her to find out what kind of demand she’d end up creating. After practically everybody she knew began begging for her now-perfected peanut butter cups, she found herself at the helm of Jessie’s Nutty Cups, and the New York City dessert scene hasn’t been the same since. There’s a whole lot of nutty goodness to get down on at Jessie’s with peanut butter cups as classic as dark sea salt and and pretzel, all the way to PB&J and Oreo. Not enough peanut butter for you in those cups? Fear not: you can also buy jars of peanut butter straight from the source, so have fun upgrading your next peanut butter and jelly sandwich. There’s a whole lot of good stuff waiting for you on the other side of your order, so book Jessie’s Nutty Cups to level up the dessert table at your next event. MUST TRY Pretzel Nutty Cup — A classic peanut butter cup with a pretzel on top to add some salty to your sweet.