Holy Cow Ice Cream Cafe
Super Great For
- On-Set Catering
- Corporate Catering
- Vegans & Vegetarians
- Weddings
Every scoop is a 'Holy Cow!' moment!



Holy Cow Ice Cream Cafe Menu
Ice Cream-Award Winners
Vanilla
Vanilla ice cream made with all-natural Madagascar Vanilla. Contains: Dairy
Ritzy AF
Salted butter cracker ice cream loaded with house-made Ritz cracker toffee bark. BEST FLAVOR IN AMERICA 2022 NAICA Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
Pistachio Baklava
Honey-infused pistachio butter base, roasted pistachio toffee, bits of crispy phyllo dough. BEST FLAVOR IN NORTHEAST 2024 NAICA Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Pistachio
Chocolate
Chocolate ice cream made with premium Dutch chocolate. Contains: Dairy
Strawberry
Strawberry ice cream made with house-made strawberry reduction. Contains: Dairy
Ice Cream-Core Flavors
Cookie Dough
Vanilla ice cream, cookie dough chunks, chocolate chips. Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy
Cookies + Cream
Vanilla ice cream, Oreos. Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy
Cold Brew Oreo
Cold brew ice cream, Oreos. Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy
Salted Caramel Brownie
Salted caramel ice cream, house-made brownie pieces, salted caramel swirl. Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
Pastel de Nata
Vanilla bean custard, chunks of house-made pastel de nata, cinnamon salted caramel swirl. Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
Minstanity
Mint ice cream, house-made double chocolate cookies, cookie dough, Golden Oreos, Oreos. Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
Salted PB Oreo
Salted peanut butter ice cream, Oreos. Contains: Dairy, Gluten, Soy & Peanuts
Cereal Milk
Fruity Pebbles infused cereal milk ice cream with cereal marshmallows. Contains: Dairy & Soy
Corner Piece
Brown butter chocolate ice cream, house-made crispy brownie corner pieces. Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
Ice Cream-Limited Time
Brown Butter Cornbread
Brown butter ice cream, house-made cornbread pieces. Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
Apple Pie
Apple cinnamon ice cream, chunks of apple, house-made graham cracker crust, cinnamon infused salted caramel. Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
Pumpkin S'mores
Pumpkin marshmallow ice cream, house-made graham cracker cookies, mini marshmallows & chocolate ganache. Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
Boston Cream Pie
Rich custard ice cream loaded with chunks of Flour Bakery + Cafe's famous Boston Cream Pie. Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
Oatmeal Cream Pie
Brown sugar buttercream ice cream, house-made oatmeal cream pie chunks. Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
Apple Cider Donut
Vanilla ice cream loaded with house-made cider donuts and cider infused salted caramel. Collab with Downeast Cider. Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
Cinnamon Churro Dough
Cinnamon brown sugar ice cream, cinnamon churro dough chunks. Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy
Ice Cream-Vegan
Vegan Purple Haze
Coconut based Ube ice cream, house-made vegan chocolate hazelnut bark. Contains: Coconut & Hazelnut
Vegan Coconut Oreo
Coconut based ice cream, GLUTEN FREE Oreos. Contains: Coconut & Soy
Vegan Cookie Butter
Coconut based cookie butter ice cream, Biscoff cookies. Contains: Coconut, Gluten & Soy
Toppings
Whipped Cream
Cherries
Peanut Butter
Peanut Butter Sauce
Walnuts
Contains nuts
Reese's Pieces
Contains nuts
Crushed Peanuts
Contains nuts
Rainbow Sprinkles
Crushed Oreos
Hot Fudge
Housemade hot fudge
Caramel
Caramel sauce
Mini M&Ms
Chocolate Sprinkles
Ice Cream Sandwiches
Mocha Madness
Chocolate cookies with chocolate chunks packed with coffee ice cream
Old Fashioned
Chocolate chip cookies with our award winning vanilla ice cream rolled in chocolate chips.
Big & Ritzy
Chocolate chip cookies with our Ritzy AF ice cream rolled in our homemade Ritzy bark
Mint Monster
Chocolate cookies with our Mintsanity ice cream and rolled in chocolate chips

About Holy Cow Ice Cream Cafe
- Mom & Pop Business
The menu balances gourmet creations, nostalgic treats, and classic favorites, with unique combinations that keep the selection exciting. House-made specialties include Salted Butter Cracker Ice Cream with Ritz Cracker Toffee Bark, Fruity Pebbles Cereal Milk, and seasonal snack cake flavors. Each visit brings something worth discovering, while made-to-order waffle cones add an irresistible finishing touch with their fresh-from-the-iron aroma and satisfying crunch.
Beyond its inventive ice cream, Holy Cow Ice Cream Cafe makes the customer experience and community connection part of its recipe. Its eye-catching atmosphere, freshly made waffle cones, and ever-changing flavor lineup give guests plenty of reasons to return. The cafe also supports charitable causes through engaging community initiatives, making it a memorable choice for Salem-area popups, private events, and gatherings seeking handcrafted ice cream with personality.
Book catering for your next event
Protected by our 100% Roaming Hunger Service Guarantee