Middleborough Pizza

Middleborough Pizza brings a slice of South Shore tradition to Hurley, New York, with a pop-up dedicated to the tavern-style pies of coastal Massachusetts. Known for their 10-inch thin pan pizzas where cheese and sauce stretch right to the edge, these pies bake up with a crispy, caramelized lacing that fans crave. The roots trace back to Middleborough, Massachusetts, but after years of experimenting with sourdough crusts, cheese blends, and Hudson Valley ingredients, this pop-up has found a way to honor the original while making it its own.

The menu highlights both classics and inventive creations. The Classic Cheese layers New York sharp cheddar with rich mozzarella, while the Vampire Slayer turns up the heat with garlic and hot pickled cherry peppers. Specials keep the offerings exciting, with combinations like pepperoni, ricotta, and hot honey on the Tony Roni or littlenecks with breadcrumbs and parsley on the Clams Casino. From the smoky Bacon and Maple Syrup Sugar Shack to the zesty El Hawaiian with chorizo and pineapple, every pie is crafted to surprise and satisfy.

By keeping South Shore Bar Pizza alive in the Hudson Valley, Middleborough Pizza has created a pop-up that feels both nostalgic and original. Each bite carries the spirit of Massachusetts taverns while showcasing the creativity and ingredients of its new home in Hurley.